(If you're looking for the Who Started Your Dream bloghop, please click here.)
------------------
In a post a few weeks ago I mentioned unconscious incompetence, which is from the Stages of Competence model I studied in a long-ago psych class. I love how this model can be applied to writing. The four stages are:
- Unconscious incompetence
- Conscious incompetence
- Conscious competence
- Unconscious competence
This chart describes each stage and shows how you move from one level to the next as you gain more skill at whatever it is you're doing--or trying to do. (Start in the upper left box and follow the arrows.)
Here's an example of the stages using my own writing journey.
Unconscious Incompetence
I wrote my first novel thinking I was the next JK Rowling, that the concept was completely unique, and in a few short months I'd see my book in print. Writing a novel wasn't all that tough. You just had to get words on the page. Whee!
Conscious Incompetence
I'm not sure when or why I realized my writing was awful--maybe after I was well into my second novel and reread my first manuscript. What a horrible, sinking feeling! I sucked! I think this is where a lot of writers quit, or if they're still motivated to write, do something about getting more competent. I joined SCBWI, found a crit group, read more middle grade and YA novels, attended conferences, and studied books on writing. On a bad writing day I'm still here.
Conscious Competence
I believe I reached this stage as I was writing my fourth novel, and it's where I find myself more often now--writing with some skill, but having to think about what I'm doing.
Unconscious Competence
The analogy I like for this stage is driving a car with a stick shift. At some point, you don't think about clutching and shifting and pressing the gas pedal; you're just driving. With writing, you're just ... writing. The feeling is similar to the first stage, only now you know what you're doing. (The danger of this stage is that you can become complacent and not put enough energy into your craft.)
One reason I like this model is because it's not about talent, which I have no control over. It's about working at something until I get it right, which I can control. Or as Ursula K. LeGuin said about writing:
You sit down and you do it, and you do it, and you do it, until you have learned to do it.

14 comments:
I recently had this convo with my CP--we discussed how we had moved into that third stage (hopefully by now) and hoped for stage four--AWESOME! THX for reminding me of this!
What an excellent reminder/teaching tool this is. I like that it leaves the way open for learning, for growth which is, ultimately, what life is all about. We are not born experts, we are born incapable of taking care of ourselves and have to learn EVERYthing.
What an awesome post! I have to agree this is a wonderful teaching tool!!
great comparrison. I learned that model years ago too as it relates to teaching/learning. It has always stuck with me.
I, for one, in the writing world, am in the Conscious incompetence stage. I am getting better though. :0)
Great post!
"Whee!" indeed. ;) Yes, I think we all start out thinking what a wonderful lark it will be and then find out how it can be more like Sisyphus' stone.
This is such a great post. Thank you.
Thanks for your thoughtful comments, everyone.
Hi There,I hope you are well. I just wanted to stop by and say a HUGE Thank you for your words of wisdom. Always nice to hear. I'm sure I'll find my way around its just finding the time to do it at the moment :)
Thanks once again and stay in touch
Eve.xxx
You're welcome, Eve. Blogger is confusing when you're first starting out. You'll be unconscious competent in no time!
I like this. Makes it seem possible to progress through the stages.
Side note: I've been smiling for months whenever I see your name in the blogosphere, reminding me of Virginia Hamilton's "M.C. Higgins the Great", a fave book from forever ago.
Robert--That's funny! I wasn't aware of the book, but I like the sound of it. :)
Great post! I hope I'm at the conscious competence level. I'm working on my craft and improving all the time.
I like your new look. I had no idea your name was Melissa. LOL, I think I've been following you for two years or so.
I love this! What a great post. And I long for the day when my writing is like driving with the stick shift--just doing it. That's a fabulous comparison, by the way.
Interesting take; it makes sense! I think I'm at the conscious incompetence stage, so here's hoping I reach the conscious competence stage in the current process!
MEL! There's something for you on my blog. Come on over and see!
Post a Comment